Thursday, May 19, 2011

Hell: what is it good for?

For the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions, and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths.
(2 Timothy 4:3-4)

This is pretty old (from a web-based media standpoint, something that came out 3 months ago might as well be written in hieroglyphics), but it's been floating around in my head for a while now.

If you haven't heard about it yet, read the New York Times' piece on Rob Bell's latest book, Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived. In it, he argues that a "loving God would never sentence human souls to eternal suffering."

In response to some questions Bell posed in his promotional video, Denny Burk laid out Biblical answers. Check out the full post on his blog, but the section where he tackles the issue of hell and why we deserve it is what got to me. He hit the nail on the head:
Sin will always appears as a trifle to those whose view of God is small. If you were to discover a little boy pulling the legs off of a grasshopper, you would think it strange and perhaps a little bizarre. If the same little boy were pulling the legs off of a frog, that would be a bit more disturbing. If it were a bird, you would probably scold him and inform his parents. If it were a puppy, that would be too shocking to tolerate. You would intervene. If it were a little baby, it would be so reprehensible and tragic that you would risk you own life to protect the baby. What’s the difference in each of these scenarios? The sin is the same (pulling the limbs off). The only difference is the one sinned against (from a grasshopper to a baby). The more noble and valuable the creature, the more heinous and reprehensible the sin. And so it is with God.
If God were a grasshopper, then to sin against Him wouldn’t be such a big deal and eternal punishment wouldn’t be necessary. But God isn’t a grasshopper, He’s the most precious, valuable, beautiful being in the universe. His glory and worth are infinite and eternal. Thus to sin against an infinitely glorious being is an infinitely heinous offense that is worthy of an infinitely heinous punishment.
We don’t take sin seriously because we don’t take God seriously. We have so imbibed of the banality of our God-belittling spirit of the age that our sins hardly trouble us at all. Our sin seems small because we regard God as small. And thus the penalty of hell—eternal conscious suffering under the wrath of God—always seems like an overreaction on God’s part. If we knew God better, we wouldn’t think like that.
And that's the crux of the problem - our society doesn't know God. We've made Him into this being who is desperate and wimpy and outdated, when in reality, He is perfect, all-powerful and more relevant than anything in the universe. But it reminds me of a C.S. Lewis quote:  
"A man can no more diminish the glory of God by refusing to worship Him than a lunatic can put out the sun by scribbling the word 'darkness' on the walls of his cell."

3 comments:

  1. I like the blog, but I have to weigh-in against your stand on the "hell" question. The obvious problem with the concept of hell - apart from the total absence of evidence that hell is anything but a typical myth - is that it is deeply counter-intuitive.

    In our judicial system ,for example, we normally seek to administer punishments in a manner which seems proportional and humane. It's a matter of controversy whether we should "water-board" terrorism suspects to try to obtain information. Compare that with, for example, torturing someone FOREVER as punishment for choosing the wrong set of beliefs about religion - in a world which (a) has always been full of disagreement about religion, and (b) has lots of physical evidence that appears to plainly disprove literal interpretations of the Bible.

    It seems like the Christian idea of this cosmic eternal rewards system is pretty much rigged in favor of the credulous. When you get to heaven don't be suprised if you find yourself surrounded by a disproportionate number of people who invested heavily in pyramid schemes and believed that Big-Foot was real.

    In the Christian fundamentalist view of this heaven-and-hell system it's as if God is playing his version of that game people play with children - in which you ask the child to guess which hand has the coin in it. Apparently, God is forcing each of us to guess whether Christianity is true (true notwithstanding all its apparently counter-factual and counter-intuitive elements). But in this game, if the child guesses wrong, instead of just not getting the coin, God punches him really hard in the face a billion times.

    Admittedly, the concept of hell is consistent with other elements of the Bible, but not in a good way. In Deuteronomy, God commanded that the other peoples in Israel (Canaanites, Perizzites, et al) be massacred, and he made it clear that they shouldn't spare the children: "You must not let anything that breathes remain alive." Most people today would rightly regard that kind of behavior as a war crime.

    It's remarkable that so many Christians just accept the implication of such Biblical passages and concepts - namely, that God is primitive and barbaric compared with humans. The simpler and more plausible explanation (and the one which is more respectful to God) is that the ancient people who created these myths were relatively primitive and barbaric, and not suprisingly they sometimes projected those traits onto their God(s).

    The same is true of their thoughts about an after-life.

    -Roger Bliss

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Roger – I believe the idea of hell is quite intuitive and extremely fair. In fact, I’ve heard the argument that hell is simply God giving people over to the deepest desire of their heart by separating Himself from them and allowing them “independence” for all eternity. It is the worst and most just punishment imaginable. (You can see more of that here: http://www.redeemer.com/news_and_events/articles/the_importance_of_hell.html )

    While the question of why God would command the execution of entire nations is a difficult one, we still have to remember that from our limited human perspective, we only see the tip of the iceberg. In Isaiah 55:8, He says, “For your thoughts are not my thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, declares the Lord.” I have plenty of questions and difficulties with these ideas, too. As Christians, the things God allows often confuse us, but we admit (in humility) that we don’t see the big picture. We are under-qualified for the job, so we trust that He knows much better than we do what He’s doing.

    Take the example of Joseph, who was sold into slavery by his brothers. Anyone looking at that from the narrow perspective of that present time would say it was unjust, even evil, for God to allow that to happen. But it’s only when we look back at the whole picture that we can see God used Joseph to save an entire nation (not to mention his very family that betrayed him) in a time of famine and drought.

    Thanks to the work of Christ, we are able to escape the punishment that we all earned by sinning against a holy and perfect God. If we really got what we deserved, we would all die the moment we sinned, so I praise Him that He even has given me this long!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Regarding the passage that states "neither are your ways my ways" -- Christianity is a bullet-proof belief system. For its followers, if something in the Bible makes sense, that's evidence of the truth of the Bible, and if something in the Bible makes no sense, that's just evidence of the truth of the various Bible passages about God's inexplicable ways. It's impossible to refute it.

    I reject the suggestion, by the way, that Christians humbly acknowledge not being able to see "the big picture." Implicit in the religion (and often in the certainty of its believers) is the assumption that they somehow have a special insight that enables them to know (even though it's not apparent to others) the specific nature of the universe - including, for example, knowing that there is an after-life and how it is structured. It's a remarkable claim that a lot of people would be too humble to make.

    -Roger Bliss

    ReplyDelete